The Supreme Court won’t hear Custodia Bank’s challenge to the Federal Reserve’s rejection of its master account application. The decision ends a years-long fight and leaves intact a lower court ruling that grants the Fed broad discretion to shut crypto-focused banks out of the federal payment system.
Custodia, a Wyoming-chartered bank built to serve digital asset clients, applied for a master account in 2020. The Fed said no. The bank sued, arguing that federal law entitles any chartered depository institution to an account. The Tenth Circuit disagreed, holding that the Fed can deny applications without much explanation. That ruling now stands.
A State Charter That Doesn’t Matter
Wyoming issued Custodia a Special Purpose Depository Institution charter specifically to bridge traditional banking and crypto. The state designed the framework to meet federal requirements, believing a valid charter would open the door to Fed services. It didn’t. The Fed slow-walked the application, then rejected it outright, citing unspecified safety and soundness concerns. Custodia’s CEO, Caitlin Long, has said publicly the central bank never pointed to a concrete deficiency in the bank’s capitalization or controls.
The Supreme Court’s refusal to take the case means the Fed’s internal criteria, whatever they are, win. No hearing, no precedent-setting opinion, just a door that stays closed. For crypto banks, the message is clear: a state charter doesn’t compel the Fed to do anything.
The Choke Point Holds
Custodia isn’t alone. Other crypto-native banks have faced similar roadblocks. The Fed’s master account system is the backbone of dollar settlement, letting banks move money between institutions without correspondent relationships. Without it, a bank is functionally locked out of the broader financial system, forced to route payments through intermediaries that often don’t want crypto exposure in the first place.
The legal theory Custodia advanced was straightforward: the Federal Reserve Act says member banks “may” hold accounts, but doesn’t hand the Fed unlimited veto power. The Tenth Circuit read “may” as permission, not obligation. The Supreme Court apparently sees no constitutional question worth its time.
That leaves the regulatory perimeter right where the Fed wants it. A bank can hold a state charter, meet every capital requirement, and still get shut out if the central bank decides digital assets are a risk it won’t accommodate. There’s no appeal beyond the circuit court, and now no chance of a Supreme Court check on that authority.
